Where art thou dionysian ubermensch, hero of human culture?

Discussion in 'Philosophy and Religion' started by Mountain Valley Wolf, May 24, 2014.

  1. ~Zen~

    ~Zen~ California Tripper Administrator

    Messages:
    14,240
    Likes Received:
    19,638
    Thanks for bumping the thread @Mountain Valley Wolf this truly needs discussion in these perilous times.
     
    kinulpture and scratcho like this.
  2. Mountain Valley Wolf

    Mountain Valley Wolf Senior Member

    Messages:
    2,929
    Likes Received:
    1,385
    Thank you!
     
  3. scratcho

    scratcho Lifetime Supporter Lifetime Supporter

    Messages:
    35,380
    Likes Received:
    17,153
    My piddling little contribution is --Herb Caan: Coined the term-hippies / hippy. San Francisco Chronicle, I believe.

    What has befallen thedope ?
     
    Last edited: Dec 13, 2023
    Mountain Valley Wolf likes this.
  4. Mountain Valley Wolf

    Mountain Valley Wolf Senior Member

    Messages:
    2,929
    Likes Received:
    1,385
    It seems that a number of people have disappeared or been inactive like myself.
     
    kinulpture and scratcho like this.
  5. scratcho

    scratcho Lifetime Supporter Lifetime Supporter

    Messages:
    35,380
    Likes Received:
    17,153
    Shame, that. I'm not knowledgeable enough to contribute, but appreciate the back and forth , the metaphorical dances.
     
    ~Zen~ and Mountain Valley Wolf like this.
  6. kinulpture

    kinulpture Member

    Messages:
    1,494
    Likes Received:
    208
    Many thanks. There is a passage in ballad of john & yoko book. Dunno howclose to real it was. But they talked of a followup show to woodstock. Where j & y were to be in psychically powered flying car.
     
    Mountain Valley Wolf likes this.
  7. MeAgain

    MeAgain Dazed & Confused Lifetime Supporter Super Moderator

    Messages:
    21,203
    Likes Received:
    15,430
    Huh, I saw this and thought "how interesting, I'll have to respond" then found I already did!

    But after all this time, nine years, I see little of value in the responses to the OP. Even my own.
    We appear to be spinning our wheels.
    The grand awakening never occurred and it appears it will not in our lifetimes, mine anyway.

    The evolution of human consciousness that saw in a minor spurt in the sixties and seventies has lost momentum and it appears it will take time to rebuilt.
    I used to prow bookstores and find wonderful books on the shelves that would leap out and demand I buy them, Be Here Now, The Book on The Taboo Against Knowing Who You Are, Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintainence, Zen Keys, Divine right's Trip, Seed, Etc., etc.
    All gone now.
    We have entered an age of self absorption, a yuppified culture of SUVs, giant pickup trucks, Uber, and Door Dash.
    All things I don't understand.

    i would be perfectly happy puttering around in my old '67 Valiant with holes in the floor, leaking oil, traveling back roads "looking for adventure".
    But that time is past and it doesn't really matter anyway.

    Que sera, sera...you can't push the river.
     
  8. kinulpture

    kinulpture Member

    Messages:
    1,494
    Likes Received:
    208
    Was a miniature rennaisance. just prior to this time. We had a visitor desperately urging changes. This has been well documented. This prompted ikes farewell adress. The concept is now called stranger @ the pentagon. & even were the visit fake. Duhznt make wot were urged any less important.
     
  9. kinulpture

    kinulpture Member

    Messages:
    1,494
    Likes Received:
    208
    So quite obviously we need to be doing things differently than what quite sadly we have mostly gotten used to. Will we be discerning enough to do whatever needs done?
     
  10. MeAgain

    MeAgain Dazed & Confused Lifetime Supporter Super Moderator

    Messages:
    21,203
    Likes Received:
    15,430
    In a word, no.

    The myth of the counter culture is that all those who dressed like "hippies", wore long hair, and took drugs were "enlightened beings".
    In reality the vast majority were merely hedonistic ego based individuals out for a good time. Very few had any understanding of what an "awakening" of mankind entailed. Or cared.

    The idea that members of the counter culture were in any way "supermen" or "superior" to their parents or the old objective, rational mind set is to misunderstand what objectivity and rationality are.
    Only a very small number of the counter culture wrestled with these concepts, or came to understand that objectivity, in particular, is just the other side of subjectivity. You can't have one without the other.
    Rationality is merely the conscious process of reaching this realization.

    The "movement" lost steam, or as some believe failed, when the vast majority of counter culture members, failing to address or even be aware of the "objectification" of culture, tired of the drugs, (LSD in particular as it led most to become terrified of ego death,) and tired of a spontaneous life, began to seek stability.
    They found philosophy, "enlightenment", and "saving the world" didn't pay the bills and hunger was a reality they couldn't ignore.
    As such they threw the baby out with the bath water and proceeded to "make a living" while giving lip service to the principles they once espoused.

    The small minority of the counter culture that actually understood what the evolution of the human mind entails via what "enlightenment" means, found that any attempt to explain this concept to others ultimately failed, if the other was not at the point of self understanding.
    In other words "enlightenment" comes from within.
    All that can be done is to provide an environment conducive to understanding.
    Unfortunately the small percentage of "enlightened" human beings, hippie or not, lack the power and influence to provide such an environment.
    So they soldier on doing the best they can.

    On the other hand, those who truly understand, or are truly "enlightened", have no interest in saving anybody or anything from any other thing or any anybody else as everything is a circle and there is nowhere to go and nothing to do.

    ...or something like that.
     
    Mountain Valley Wolf and ~Zen~ like this.
  11. ~Zen~

    ~Zen~ California Tripper Administrator

    Messages:
    14,240
    Likes Received:
    19,638
    That is a bit fatalistic, but sadly true in most cases.

    Seems materialism won in the battle for altruism vs. greed.

    But surprisingly there are some left who saw through the illusions - they mostly despair as they are few and far between.
     
    scratcho and MeAgain like this.
  12. kinulpture

    kinulpture Member

    Messages:
    1,494
    Likes Received:
    208
    Some mini golden ages last longer than others. A 12000yr stranglehold is a bit difficult to overcome. & what we may traditionally think of as enlightenment may not look like it. Because its being fought tooth & nail. Hippies had benefit of previous beat. A new one aint got that. Think of prez debates starting with lincoln douglas.
     
  13. scratcho

    scratcho Lifetime Supporter Lifetime Supporter

    Messages:
    35,380
    Likes Received:
    17,153
    Yes, it certainly can be difficult to maintain one's principles and act on them for the betterment of society when living in this capitalist trip where rent or mortgage , food , transportation, having kids and everything else that requires almost full time attention is a constant onslaught---those are of course--one's own decisions.
     
  14. Mountain Valley Wolf

    Mountain Valley Wolf Senior Member

    Messages:
    2,929
    Likes Received:
    1,385

    No man! That was only the chicks, man. LMAO! I'm Joking---but that's a pretty good egotistical sexist hippie joke.

    I wasn't referring to just objectivism, or just rationalism, as those are always important and are necessary for us to understand and work with our reality, but a rationalist-objectivism which is the negative aspects of these things as they shaped the modern world from Cartesian Objectivism. It is why humans are objectified into mere numbers and are slaves to their personal histories and credit status. It was not something brand new mind you, as slavery is a good example that goes well into our past. But Cartesian Objectivism elevated it. I would describe it as the Apollonian aspects of objectivism and rationalism. And while objectivism is the opposite of subjectivism, it is the dominant force of civilization, and civilization is grounded upon it. Derrida argued that every such set of binary opposites would be subject to deconstruction, and the dominant side would be replaced with the marginalized side. His philosophy came out in the 50's and was big in university philosophy departments at the time, which had no bearing on the hippie movement as it was an organic deconstruction of objectivism that rose up naturally. But it helped validate it to some students I'm sure.

    The fact that the masses have little understanding of what is really going on, or the ideology of what they are a part of, is typical of every movement. Very few MAGA Republicans understand the blatant fascism that their movement espouses, despite it being right in their faces. In fact, I would imagine that more hippies understood, in their own way, what the hippie movement was about, than many other movements in history of that scale.

    Was it a mistake for the hippies to embrace poverty? Or was that key to their enlightenment? That is a tough debate. I agreed with Jerry Rubin when he said that you cannot achieve freedom without economic freedom.

    In retrospect, I refer to my life in the 1980's as when I was seduced by the dark side. I had a taste of money, power and fame, and it certainly corrupted me. It ended in hubris, but at least I got to keep the girl--not my first wife, mind you, but the mistress I fell head over heels for. I was not proud of what I did to my first wife, on the other hand, she certainly played her role in making it happen. In the end, it too was part of my path, a path shared by many baby boomers.

    I do think that Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs explains a lot to this.


    Zarathustra in Nitezsche's book, Thus Spoke Zarathustra, is actually his example of the ubermensch, and this is basically how it ends---he realizes that he can't change everyone, that he can only change himself, and everyone else, on their own path, have to find their own enlightenment.

    I will write more on this later.
     
  15. kinulpture

    kinulpture Member

    Messages:
    1,494
    Likes Received:
    208
    While i do know a few folks here in the ozarks who do kinda have it a bit ez. There do seem some tradeoffs such as paranoia & insularity. How would we utilize o lets just say a genuine hoverboard? One couldnt utilize one as driven daily. A couple yrs ago i scared a trucker just with a
     
  16. kinulpture

    kinulpture Member

    Messages:
    1,494
    Likes Received:
    208
    Razor scooter & a long coat. He thought i was a ghost as he diidnt see the scooter. He was parked on side of road.
     
  17. Mountain Valley Wolf

    Mountain Valley Wolf Senior Member

    Messages:
    2,929
    Likes Received:
    1,385
    (I pulled the first four paragraphs from my last post in the thread Sexual Morality, but it fits here too:)

    I have a painting, in charcoal ink, of Chinese calligraphy of a single character hanging near my dining room. It is the Chinese name of the third hexagram of the I-Ching. It is written Chun in my Chinese character dictionary, which is fairly old. I believe the modern version would be Zhun which is supposed to be closer to the pronunciation. I don't know. I am fluent in Japanese, and while I know enough Chinese grammar to read much of it, I don't speak Chinese so I tend to use Japanese pronunciations of Chinese characters, or if I look up a character, it is with my old Chinese character dictionary.

    Chun means difficulty or chaos, and generally refers to a difficult start or beginning. The character actually represents the sprout of a plant as it first struggles to break free in order to one day become a tree, or a bush or a flower. It is written that for something great to be achieved, it must first rise up out of chaos. In English we say, it is always the darkest before the light. This painting is very significant to me, because it is more than just a darkness before the morning light---it speaks to the philosophy of Nietzsche who I think has a lot to say about this period we are living in, and even social movements and trends in general. Nietzsche was writing during Europe's fin-de-siecle which was the end of the bourgeoisie era, and culminated in the death rattles of World War I and World War II. He wrote quite a bit about the two dynamics of power that play in any poltical-social situation and I agree strongly, having observed it in the corporate world. These two dynamics are the Dionysian and the Apollonian. I revived an old post on the ubermensch in this philosophy forum that discusses this so I won't get into it, other than to say that one of the best examples of the Dionysian in nature is that of a sprout that struggles, but has the unbridled energy and strength to burst from the ground, even from under concrete and stone.

    I would say that, in order to survive and be victorious in the struggles I referred to in the first paragraph (of the post I pulled this from, but which is basically the same problem we are discussing here), we need to see a reappearance of the Dionysian, as we did the hippies in the early 60's. In keeping with the OP, the Dionysian is very sexual---a revolution in sexual ethics. It may very well be that the launch pin that gets our youngest generation active on this is the repressive abortion laws that parts of our nation is succumbing to.

    But I have observed various things over the past several decades that give me hope. A reawakening of old spirits, if you will. A deconstruction of old ways, necessary to give birth to new ways. Alvin Toffler, in his book, The Third Wave, touches upon things that I have also seen, trends at play, and so forth. I think a lot of the populist movements and the right wings radicalism---very Apollonian in nature, is a reaction to positive things that are happening.

    The problem is that we thought we'd change the world overnight in the 60's. We did bring quite a bit of change to the world, and some of it was far reaching and is still significant today, such as with music. But in my own research and observation of how philosophy plays out in, and shapes, human history I have come to the conclusion that real change takes a long time. Revolutions tend not to change the underlying culture, or the underlying problems that created the revolution, just as The Who sang in We Won't Get Fooled Again. For real change you need to undergo a process of evolution.

    I feel that the hippie movement was like the sprout struggling to grow forth. In many ways what we are experiencing today is a reaction to the 60's. Of course, the risk is that any progress that was made could be chopped away, and quashed completely. And sadly, the real change may not occur in our lifetimes. But if we don't give up on it, if we keep the spark alive by passing the ideals down through the generations.

    But as the spark passes on, it will be received, perceived, and interpreted differently by future generations---it becomes theirs, and it is up to them to give it meaning for their generation.
     
  18. kinulpture

    kinulpture Member

    Messages:
    1,494
    Likes Received:
    208
    Was thinking of rereading fs & 3rdwave. Those as i recall were somewhat ez as one really didnt hafta change much. As opposed to zeitgeist or peaceful warrior. Ive always liked small is beautiful. & an embarrasment of riches. It really duhznt take a megaton of education & research to know changes r necessary. Im really excited abt fresh air architechvral concepts. & im glad organic concepts didnt go entirely extinct. Did yall
    know that sugar duhznt hafta be labeled as being beet based?
     
  19. MeAgain

    MeAgain Dazed & Confused Lifetime Supporter Super Moderator

    Messages:
    21,203
    Likes Received:
    15,430
    I believe the revolution in sexual ethics has already mostly occurred.
    When I was a teenager, or even in college, porn was a back room, hard to find item. Now it's everywhere.
    Just walk into a Spencer's Gift Shop.

    The abortion debate certainly is having an effect, but only becasue it affects the individual. Few realize that the effort to eliminate abortions isn't really about individual abortions, it's about the desire to impose a certain religion on an entire nation. If the abortion issue is resolved in favor of individual choice, the movement to instill a theocracy will continue in different ways.
    I was listening to NPR the other day, unfortunately I missed most of the discussion, but I caught the part wherein the interviewee was explaining that the drive for home schooling and school choice was not about the desire to have a better education for ones' child, it's about the destruction of the public school system. I assume because it gets in the way of religious indoctrination.

    I agree the current cultural leaning toward a theocratic dictatorship is a backlash of the "60s" progressive era.
    This leaning is being propelled by those who lack the capacity to understand history or current events. They have no empathy and very little critical thinking skills.

    That's nothing new. During the entire history of the human race the vast majority has also had little empathy and critical thinking skills. The difference is that in the past those people had little or no access to each other. They were held in check by the elite of their own particular era be it government or religion. They towed the line. They went about their daily lives.

    With the advent of "The Third Wave", the internet and cable TV in particular, they have found a voice and united.
    In short the majority of the human race has always been, for want of a better word, stupid, but today stupid has become a badge of honor.

    Now, I will freely admit that I'm not the sharpest tool in the shed, but I know that and try to act accordingly.
    It seems to me that today most people feel they are smarter than everyone else and, as they now have access to third wave mechanisms they have no problem declaring that to the world.


    The spark, as you call it, is at the point where it may ignite into a conflagration instead of lighting the Athenian lamp of learning.
    This coming presidential election will tell the tale.
     
  20. Mountain Valley Wolf

    Mountain Valley Wolf Senior Member

    Messages:
    2,929
    Likes Received:
    1,385
    I was very lucky and privileged when I was young. My parents had all the National Geographics going all the way back into the 20's, and a few odd ones going back a decade further. (...oh yeah, and my dad usually had a playboy in a lower desk drawer.)



    I listened to that---it was a good episode. I believe the program was On the Media, but it was one of those shows that has a podcast of their episodes. I was going to send it to my son, because sometimes he talks crazy stuff about the school that his daughters is in---promoting transgender stuff. I don't know where he is getting that idea from. He is liberal raised by me, but sometimes he goes on off on these tangents. The episode also talked about how Mom's of Liberty are spreading that kind of misinformation to shock Christians into turning against the schools. etc.

    Yep, I agree. Or we may collapse into an authoritarian dictatorship that will destroy the country. It is a critical election. And as far as technology--the internet is like a new toy that we can't stop playing with yet. We have a lot of learning to do in terms of how it can benefit society and how to protect truth and objective reality, and avoid its addictive aspects, as just some of the ways we need to mature with it.

    The dumb masses have always just been along for the ride. The real change that is happening, and that may allow this spark to grow and elevate mankind to his next step of evolution is happening, and will happen in the science and philosophy departments of our universities. These changes occur in time over ways we probably don't recognize, and they happen overtime, influencing our collectiove unconscious and our social programming. I mentioned recently how deconstruction was so big in philosophy departments in the late 50's and early 60's. Hippies very much represented deconstruction of our culture and norms. Or consider how Newtonian physics and empiricism gave us a very mechanical view of our universe for much of the Modern Age. But Einstein's relativity provided us a more relativistic view of the universe, and I would argue that this finally represented a culture of relativism in the 60's and beyond. Quantum physics is only beginning to alter our view of reality. We haven't even begun to face the philosophical implications of quantum physics which is what quite a bit of my writing is about. For one thing, Newtonian science/empiricism was very dualistic, Relativity began breaking down that duality, softening the edges, and turning it less polarized. Quantum mechanics presents us with a very multiplistic and subjective universe.
     
    ~Zen~ likes this.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice