This is a good one, with a slight modification. I think I'll just say the chemistry isn't there. True enough without putting too strong a focus on the sexual part. Some people can be sensitive about that. And... sigh... I know there's ultimately no perfect way to do this. Some people will get their feelings hurt no matter what. But that can't be helped. Thanks everyone for your input!!
They might just think you're kinky. They might just HOPE you're kinky. And no problemo Blues, we've mastered the art of rejection.
"I know you feel that way about me, but, Even though I care deeply about you, I do not share your feelings at this point in my life."
Easy: "You're a great person/friend but I feel we're not compatible." Edit: Actually, I like "(...) but I don't have romantic feelings for you" better.
This is really true. Once I was trying to be really nice about it, ya know? And the guy turned into a damn stalker. It's like his brain couldn't compute "no" and being nice at the same time. I had to threaten restraining order and a phone call to his mom before he finally stopped.
Tell them that your last BF stretched you out, so now you only date guys with at least a 10" johnson.