what is more musical (to you)

just wondering which of these naturally ocurring sounds you find to be the most musical... and if it (the sound) has any other signifigance for you

 

The first two remind me of Pet Sounds so they have my full support. Police sirens produce an effect more like a nervous breakdown to me..

 

yeah, seein as how i was apprehended by the police last night (public drunkeness, glad im still a minor), i dont like police sirens either. but the sound made by a train is... i like its rhythm, fast or slow, it doesnt matter... choo choo

 

i picked the train as well

 

Have to the train, hit a steady speed over jointed track and you have a steady rythmn for hours..

Shame you couldn't pick two tho, love the sounds of wind.

 

I've chosen the whistling wind, that's so relaxing

But...an old man falling down stairs...wtf

 

windddddd

 

definately the train...

 

eh... depends on what the old man was carrying, its a mixed bag with the old man

 

would i could vote again... the old man is now making music in my cranium... the clinking and clanking of pots and pans, the sound of decaying bones being crushed against the concrete of my brain's 7 story apartment building... imagination is glorious!

 

the wind also comes to mind as musical....actually, that's my new choice.

 

in fact, the old man falling is quite jazzy... all the different grunts and the sound of bones cracking... splattered with profanity and the sound of whatever he has dropped continuing to fall with him... give it a grammy!

 

The dog would definately be right up Pink Floyd's alley...think of it...it would fit right into Animals.

 

The wind for sure.

 

I choose the train..I adoore that sound, it's the sound of freedom, of travelling

 

trains are actually not in the least bit free... they're stuck on a track for all their lives and don't get to choose where they go.. when their time is up they're thrown into a junkyard.

but hey thats what i picked too. :H

 

I think that I'll be really free If I could get the first train on the station and go somewhere...that's what I want to say

 

Like someone else said the dog barking is like Animals. But the wind kinda reminds me of ''Shine On You Crazy Diamond'' on Wish You Were Here.

 

If there were no trains, there would be no rock and roll and the blues would never exist.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W.C._Handy
http://www.cr.nps.gov/delta/blues/people/wc_handy.htm

 

police sirens are naturaly occuring sounds?
since when?
same with trains, theyre not exactly naturaly occurring, yet they can be pretty musical//we used to have our drum circles near the tracks & when the trains came screachin round the corner it made the most amazing sounds.. but still i had to choos the wind through the meadow option since the trains on theyre own arent that musical without the heartbeat of the drum