The debate is over...

Discussion in 'U.K.' started by fountains of nay, May 17, 2007.

  1. fountains of nay

    fountains of nay Planet Nayhem!

    Prince Harry will not be going to Iraq:

    http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/6664319.stm

    Military commanders are considering Prince Harry's future role in the Army after deciding it is too dangerous for him to serve in Iraq.


    They are hoping to secure the prince's career amid suggestions his credibility as a serving officer has been damaged.

    The head of the Army, General Sir Richard Dannatt, has said there would be "unacceptable risks" involved if Harry were deployed to Iraq.

    The prince is said to be disappointed, but committed to his army future.

    'Direct threats'

    On Wednesday the general said the prince's deployment would pose too much of a threat to him and those serving alongside him.

    "There have been a number of specific threats, some reported some not reported, which relate directly to Prince Harry as an individual," he said. "These threats expose not only him but also those around him to a degree of risk that I now deem unacceptable."



    The army chief described the prince as an officer of "determination and undoubted talent" and said he did not rule out deploying the 22-year-old prince to the region in the future.

    The announcement, which represents a U-turn on an earlier decision, was made amid reports militant groups in Iraq planned to kill or kidnap the prince.

    Last month the Ministry of Defence had said the prince would be heading to Iraq as an armoured reconnaissance officer in the Blues and Royals regiment.

    But on Wednesday, the general said he had reached his decision following a visit to the region at the end of last week.

    Dickie Arbiter, who was formerly press secretary to the Queen, said the matter had been handled "pretty badly."

    He said: "Right at the very beginning they should have said 'We will assess' without putting Harry's hopes up that he was going to go.

    "He'll be disappointed... that he can't go with his men, the men he's trained with for months to do this job."

    Mr Arbiter added that if Harry had been captured then he "would have been paraded, sack over his head, notice around his neck on television, on the web, probably with a knife at his throat".

    Credibility damaged

    The U-turn has focused attention on Harry's future and the role of the royals in the modern military services.

    Major Charles Heyman, editor of Armed Forces UK, said he thought the prince would almost certainly leave the Army.

    While he could be found a "non-job" to keep him "out of trouble", he would be left without credibility by the decision not to deploy him to Iraq, Major Heyman said.

    When Harry's uncle, Prince Andrew, returned from the Falklands conflict in 1982 he said if he had not gone his position in the Royal Navy would have become untenable.

    Following the Army's decision, some families of those killed in Iraq have questioned why their relatives should be sent to the front line when the third in line to the throne is not.

    Reg Keys - whose son Thomas was killed while on active service in Basra in 2003 - said he found the decision distasteful. "It would appear that Harry's life is more valuable than my son or the other nearly 150 service personnel who've given their lives," Mr Keys added.
     
  2. Peace-Phoenix

    Peace-Phoenix Senior Member

    It's a sensible decision from a strategic point of view, but thoroughly undermines any pretence that all soldiers are equal citizens and that giving one's life for one's country is to be encouraged in a 'just war'....
     
  3. CrucifiedDreams

    CrucifiedDreams Members

  4. Roffa

    Roffa Senior Member

    It's interesting to compare this with Prince Andrew, who did serve in the Falklands and put himself in harm's way.

    The big difference is that the Falklands war was a conventional military engagement against an enemy that respected the rules of war, not shadowy militias aiming to kidnap and hold him to ransom and possibly behead him on video.
     
  5. ROFLMAO -
    what a fucking pansy they should have sent Action man in alone.
    episode from his diary
    Oh daddy would be upset if it was actually his boy that was bheaded rather than the usual working class munter ! now I will be home safe and killing anyone that says I am gay
     

Share This Page


  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice