95% of what i listen to is stuff i haven't heard before. i keep track of the good shit and move on. there's way too much out there to ever get close to hearing everything
The more unpleb-like you want to be, the more you are. Not necessarily saying you must like pop music or r&b for that.
I´m mainly a weird outsider who likes some Artrock and Shoegaze but I´ll definitly not qualify to be "That Guy"
I seriously can not identify with any of those levels in particular. The combination with the music genres don't make sense to me so I couldn't apply it to me if I want to. Shoegaze is pretty boring to me though.