Is It Wrong To Own Nazi Paraphernalia?

Discussion in 'History' started by psymon*, May 4, 2017.

  1. psymon*

    psymon* shadilay

    I'm referring to authentic Nazi memorabilia only. Not new products made post WWII.

    My neighbor up my street had a collection of historic memorabilia, and he did have a few authentic Nazi products. He was a WWII vet as well. It seems that these days owning anything with a confederate flag or a swastika will get someone in trouble.
     
  2. r0llinstoned

    r0llinstoned Gute Nacht, süßer Prinz

    Depends who you ask. I don't have a problem with it. But in this day and age people will cry about anything.
     
  3. Irminsul

    Irminsul Valkyrie

    Hell no! I have all my grandparents gear from uniforms to iron crosses to the rifles they used. :) I've got a stick grenade, dials from shot down British war planes they collected. Panzercorps medals, totenkopf insignia, SS insignias, battle flags, battle jacks, shell casings, NDSAP document cards, party joining cards. You name it, down to the letter they wrote home.

    The Nazis were without a doubt the best dressed and best looking unit of any modern war and without doubt, original authentic militaristia sells for a fortune.

    My grandfathers first class iron cross, in the original presentation case and documents I could sell for a small fortune. And that's only one medal of theirs. ;)
     
  4. StellarCoon

    StellarCoon Shadow Warrior

    Nazi sympathizers usually don't have a problem with it. The issue that people have with this sort of thing is not with the Nazi paraphernalia itself, but with the suspect and unclear intentions/mentality of the owner.
     
    1 person likes this.
  5. newo

    newo Lifetime Supporter Lifetime Supporter

    My father brought back some Nazi daggers and bayonets from the war, and after he died my mother sold them to a war souvenier store. Nothing wrong with it, in fact I always thought they were pretty cool. That doesn't mean it's okay to fly the Nazi German flag outside your house, and I also don't approve of flying the Confederate flag.
     
  6. Irminsul

    Irminsul Valkyrie

    Unclear intentions? :D

    The intention is somebody bought it because they wanted it. Anything further is just petty scrutinization by someone who wants to have an argument about it.

    Two collectors having a discussion:

    Hey where did you find this? Is that a genuine second class iron cross? I see the swastika hasn't been ground down, great find well done"
    "Yes I bought this at an auction in Louisiana, I did the magnet test to prove its authenticity, im really please with it"

    Some uneducated dickwank:

    "Hey errrmerrrgod is that a swastika errrmagod are you like a Nazi or something errmerrrgod you're a terrible person errrr errrr *more shit dribble*"
     
    2 people like this.
  7. BlackBillBlake

    BlackBillBlake Hip Forums Supporter HipForums Supporter

    My son in law collects military stuff, including Nazi memorabilia. Latest addition, a de-commissioned Mauser rifle to add to the uniforms, medals and other bits and pieces.

    He also has a large collection of books about Hitler and his cohorts. When I first met him years ago, I was a bit worried that my daughter was getting involved with a Nazi sympathizer, but really he's not. He just finds it all fascinating.
     
  8. YouFreeMe

    YouFreeMe HipForums Supporter

    As Ygg pointed out, it has less to do with the stuff itself than the reason that someone has it.

    I had an aquaintance who was a Neo Nazi and genuinelly believed that Jewish folks and minorities should be exterminated--he used some authentic and more
    modern Nazi paraphenalia to decorate his belongings and make his beliefs known. Questionable usage of these items.

    But again I know some WW2 vets who have similar items from WW2 and keep them for reasons similar to what Irm was describing. No problems there. A lot of museums would be considered immoral by this logic (owning nazi paraphrnalia = bad).
     
  9. GLENGLEN

    GLENGLEN Lifetime Supporter Lifetime Supporter

    I Guess When It All Boils Down To It........It's Just History.......BUT...... I Wouldn't Want Any

    Of That Crap In My House Thank You......That's Why We Have Museums...... :)



    Cheers Glen.
     
    2 people like this.
  10. drumminmama

    drumminmama Super Moderator

    My soon to be ex partner has some authentic WWII items.
    Once I moved in, they got a case with a lid, so I didn't have to see them.
    They were his dad's.
     
  11. thefutureawaits

    thefutureawaits Well-Known Member

    No chance. Being that is associated with a killing machine. Not within a hundred feet of my house
     
  12. Scratched

    Scratched Well-Known Member

    Not even fifty feet?
     
  13. pensfan13

    pensfan13 Senior Member

    Hope you have a big property. You never know what the guy next door has hidden away.
     
    1 person likes this.
  14. puff n stuff

    puff n stuff Well-Known Member

    Destroy it all and you can erase history. Keep it and it is a reminder of what happened. You can not sell it in the USA on eBay
     
  15. thefutureawaits

    thefutureawaits Well-Known Member

    i like to interview my neighbors to see if they are Nazi sympathisers. Just in case.
     
  16. Scratched

    Scratched Well-Known Member

    So are you CIA?

    Or FEMA...I doubt they will tell you...for all you know they could be serial killers or North Koreans planted here.

    Or maybe it's just the Cunninghams :)
     
  17. psymon*

    psymon* shadilay

    Tru dat!

    It's politically incorrect to say this. But Nazi uniforms are dope as fuck!
     
  18. psymon*

    psymon* shadilay

    That makes sense. Owning Nazi artifacts is one thing, but having it out in the open where everybody can see is a different story.

    The thing is that many people over the years have gone out of their way to destroy authentic Nazi artifacts. All this did was create a scarcity, which inevitably led to higher demand of the products that exist today. Now, people are buying Nazi products as investments because there are collectors out there who will pay top dollar for taboo and controversial historic artifacts. And that stuff is only gonna go up in value.
     
  19. Asmodean

    Asmodean Slo motion rider

    It depends on the details as always:

    No. It's not wrong by definition to own and/or collect nazi stuff.
    Yes. Motivation and mindset of the owner/collector matters.

    Same with being intrigued by and/or having a love for the german side and story during WW2. It's not wrong by definition at all, but yeah.. it can take a dubious turn. Obviously :p People who act oblivious to that possibility (but i would emphasize its only a possibility at first instance) are annoying: because they're either stupid or ignorant on the subject, or simply being dishonest.
     
  20. Piaf

    Piaf Senior Member

    Ygg, Irm....
    Well aren't we friendly.

    And to be on topic, I don't think it's wrong, if you're into history, and not a neonazi.
     

Share This Page