Creamy Shrimp Sandwiches 4 bagels -- split 1 4 1/4 oz. *can shrimp -- rinsed and drained 1 3 oz. package cream cheese -- softened 2 tablespoons mayonnaise 1 tablespoon lemon juice 1/2 teaspoon dried dill 1 small avocado Toast bagels if desired. Mix the remaining ingredients except avocado. Top 4 bagel halves with shrimp mixture. Top with avocado slices and remaining bagel halves. * I prefer to use "real" shrimp, not canned.