a hollowed canteloupe, watermelon, pumpkin or fruit pie (very lightly warmed) (American Pie, yes, yes...); anyone care to share your experience doing so?
I absolutely love cumming in my bed spreads (some call them comforters.) I know this doesn't seem exactly in line with what you were asking, as it's not soft and wet like a vagina. But let me tell you, bunch up a comforter on your bed in a big mound and find a spot where there's already a pretty good fold in the the layers. Work that fold a little bit to make it the right size, and height and deep enough. Then stick your hard dick in there and hump the ever lovin' fuck out of the comforter while you fuck between the folds of fabric. Don't stop when you're getting close. Just cum the fuck right in there. You will know pleasure, my friend. I did it for a GF who wanted to see it for herself. She was pretty damn turned on and made herself cum right before I shot my load into the bed spread.
I remember cumming in a male masturbator and the cum just covering my cock head got me hard again. I have cum in some pretty unusual stuff over the years to catch my cum