Keira Knightley or Scarlett Johansson?

Absolutely

 

Ok, I won't. I was referring with the prejudiced thing about that page in the gym thread you linked to though. I do share your opinion on comments like you can never be too thin

 

I would prefer Scarlett appearance-wise but Keira's voice is so insanely sexy that I say they're equally attractive.

 

Thanks that is appreciated

Ahh.. Do you mean the thread itself or the last bits?

Yeah, imo people who say stuff like that are taking it much too lightly. There are far too many people out there battling eating and body disorders to make a comment like that.

 

:cheers2:

 

I don't particularly care about the rudeness of that comment, but more about that it's utter nonsense while meaning it seriously.
And I still think despite all the body disorders people are sometimes too critical these days about fatties or skinny people. I mean, if you really know that it's a disorder ok, but I see people alot of the time judge on site as well.

I've red only page 13 off the gym thread by the way.

 

Knightley is significantly more attractive IMO.

Johanson seems to have heavy features.Maybe her face isn't as lean.Maybe its the heavier chin.She just doesn't strike me as that special in alot of her pics.
Knightley is genuinely beautiful if sometimes *slightly* too thin.

Anyways, here's what I want for Xmas:-

or this:-

Both thin but not ridiculously so.

 

I don't think I have said Keira is/was anorexic. I've said she was, in my eyes, unhealthy. Which I still believe is true. I don't understand how some people could consider her frame (in those pics) "normal" and "healthy".

It's ok, gym thread is not a prerequisite

 

arty:

 

Now this one is very "thin" looking, but actually very athletic IMO.

Much better than Johanson IMO..

 

They are both equally unattractive.

 

That's not Keira is it?

 

both girls are amazing. but if I had a gun to my head and I had to choose...........


I guess I'd get shot.

 

Nope.Irina Shakykislamosomething.

..Irina Shayk.

 

LauraMay, there isn't a comparison in my eyes. Keira is a pretty lady and all (not forgetting that bloody sexy accent mmm) but as you say she does looks unhealthy and Scarlet at the very least looks like the greek goddess Athena with DDs

 

I completely agree

P.S Congrats on your 2000th post

 

I can't see any ribs...

Although she's covering the hips...

I'll say athletic

 

Skinny can be healthy you know... I'm 107 lbs but perfectly healthy and certainly not boney. Either way, I think they're both beautiful girls. Keira does seem to show a little too much stomach muscle and bone for her size, but she has a beautiful face.

 

With those abs, her ribs are gonna stick out.

I think no neck is a good indicator of underweight- like that idiot Victoria Adams.
Or the "Karaoke Skeleton" as I prefer to call her..

 

If I had to pick it would be Scarlett.But really I don't think either is that attractive.And whats with the 'anorexic look' being so fashionable nowadays.