gentle mysteries

Discussion in 'Poetry' started by teh-horace, Aug 4, 2008.

  1. teh-horace

    teh-horace for your pleasure

    Messages:
    8,114
    Likes Received:
    4
    the gentle mysteries

    i don't know what tomorrow looks
    like, other than a white square
    on a grid of others with red numbers
    in the top left corners. i do know
    what the tiny circle not fully shaded
    in means on the right corner.
    in between full and new, the number
    says three, though i know tomorrow
    is the third for the 221st time
    in my less than two decade life.
    i don't know if tomorrow is green
    and full of white daisies with bees
    dancing erotically from flower to flower
    or if tomorrow is blue like a caribbean
    sea, washing up on golden-white sands,
    grabbing at the ankles of brown-skinned
    beauties. i don't know if tomorrow,
    john of revelations will be correct
    and battle between heaven and hell
    will begin. i do know that tomorrow
    isn't here yet, and i have all day to prepare.

    -may3'07
     
  2. redyelruc

    redyelruc The Yard Man

    Messages:
    9,246
    Likes Received:
    3
    This is a nice simple poem, containing some nice tangible images. I like it a lot, but I do think that it could benefit from some punctuation. I’m not sure why you have chosen not to use capitals, maybe to create a stream of consciousness effect, but I think that this just makes the poem a little amateurish. Anyway, I’ve gone through the poem line by line below, just to highlight any places that I saw room for improvement. But my suggestions are to be taken with a pinch of salt.

    don’t now what tomorrow looks like, *I thought the line break after looks was sort of pointless and actually weakened the impact of ‘looks like’.
    other than a white square
    on a grid of others[,] with red numbers
    in the top left-[hand] corners. *a line break here would serve to strengthen the difference between what you do and don’t know.
    [But] I do know the meaning
    of the tiny circle not fully shaded,
    in the other corner. # I rearranged this a little cos I thought it read a little awkwardly the way you had means on the right corner. After already saying left corner, other corner can do the job of describing where, just as well.
    In between full and new, the number
    says three, and i know tomorrow * I thought ‘though’ was the wrong word choice. Why if the number is actually three, do you need “though”.
    is the third for the 221st time
    in my (less than two decade) life.
    I would snip ‘less than two decade’ as it is just re-itterating what you’ve said but in far less poetic terms.
    don't know if tomorrow is green
    and full of white daisies with bees
    [who dance] from flower to flower[,]
    *Although dancing erotically is nice, it doesn’t provide as immediate an image as ‘who dance’
    or if tomorrow is blue like a Caribbean * why the line break?
    sea, washing up on golden-white sands,
    grabbing at the ankles of brown-skinned
    beauties. don't know if tomorrow,
    john of revelations will be correct
    and [the]battle between heaven and hell * no need to spell out heaven and hell after talking about evelations. I already know who the battle will be between.
    will begin. [But] do know that tomorrow
    isn't here yet, and have all day to prepare.

    I thought this was a well considered poem and I do like the imagery. I did feel that adding ‘But’ throughout the piece strengthened the feeling of comparison between what you knew and what you didn’t. As I said, these are just some of the places where I got hung up a little. I am in workshop mode recently, so I hope you have no hangups about my criticisms, as they are meant to prove helpful to you on any further re-drafts.

    Thanks for posting this,
    Keep writing.
    Aidan.

    my draft of your poem:

    I don’t now what tomorrow looks like,
    other than a white square on a grid
    of others, with red numbers
    in the top left-hand corners.
    But I do know the meaning
    of the tiny circle not fully shaded,
    in the other corner.
    In between full and new, the number
    says three, and i know tomorrow is the third
    for the 221st time in my life.
    I don't know if tomorrow is green
    and full of white daisies with bees
    who dance from flower to flower,
    or if tomorrow is blue like a Caribbean sea,
    washing up on golden-white sands,
    grabbing at the ankles of brown-skinned
    beauties. I don't know if tomorrow,
    john of revelations will be correct
    and the battle will begin.

    But I do know that tomorrow
    isn't here yet, and I have all day to prepare.

     
  3. teh-horace

    teh-horace for your pleasure

    Messages:
    8,114
    Likes Received:
    4
    awesome

    i appreciate the hell out of your effort and your critique

    this was a first draft poem from long ago i just came across and made copypasta out of it

    suggestions duly noted
     
  4. Arcade Fire1987

    Arcade Fire1987 Guest

    Messages:
    4
    Likes Received:
    0
    That was pretty nice of him to edit it. It was a nice poem, he did a good job of cutting out some of the rough edges. Usually you want to avoide cliches like heaven and hell.

    I like to sort of string random images into wierd concepts too, was fun to read what its like.
     
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice