Pink Floyd

Every Pink Floyd album is amzing I reckon, I can honestly say that I bileve they have never done a bad album. Wish You Were Here is proberly my fave though

 

momentary lapse of reason was nothing special.

apparently division bell and the final cut were bad too but i havent heard them. other than that i think i've heard all the albums.

 

Hello,

My favourite album is meddle but i dont really like the division bell

Pink floyd are one of my most favourite bands and wish I could see them live and am gutted i did not see them at live8 real historical moment seeing them toghether on stage again.

 

here's my floyd theory:

no waters=no floyd.

 

ok so they weren't so great without Waters, but come on, he was only one dude in a band of four, they all contributed stuff, so thats kinda harsh...and besides, couldn't you say that the 'true' Pink Floyd died when Syd left, cos he was at the time their main musical writing force and gave the band its image and vision...just my opinion though...

 

Animals by a longshot. Probably WYWH, The Wall, and Meddle next in that order.

Floyd are always great, even in their darkest hour(imo The Final Cut). When Waters left, they were still fantastic. Not as creative, just more straightforward rock and roll, but still fantastic.

 

as i adore roger waters ý have to say "the final cut" also i get my self ýnto fantasy and dream world ýn the album "meddle". forget about it.they are all my favorites.

 

thats a well thought formule you have wrýtten.we can also say floyd=syd, can't we?
kiss you lot dear.

 

I like Ummagumma, Meddle, Wish You Were Here. Fav song "be careful with that axe Eugene", but Echos is right up there.

 

Ahh... Ummagumma. Who could forget Several Species of Small Furry Animals Gathered in a Cave and Grooving With a Pict? I'm also big on Animals and Wish You Were Here.

I've heard the Wall so many times in my life that I'm currently avoiding it at all costs. It's a great piece of work that has been seriously overplayed throughout the past 25 years. Sure, Dark Side has been played just as much, but it wasn't my introduction to Floyd like the Wall was. I hope to get to a point where I can sit down and listen through it again. Maybe another year before I give it a go.

 

Yes, but Pink Floyd is still good after he leaves. Its like two seperate bands. PATGOD belongs to Syd. The rest is Roger's and David's band.

 

I love 'The Wall' .. A collection of classics .. "wish you were here' .. 'Brick in the wall pt2', 'Hey You', 'Comfortably Numb', 'The Thin Ice', 'One of my turns' ..

superb !!

:>

 

definately between piper and saucerful...
if i had to pick ide say piper because that album is great.

I prefer their earlier stuff by far, but darkside and the wall arnt that bad really...ive found the wall to be addictive actually lol

 

.......

 

Dark Side of The Moon all the way

 

Almost certainly 'Dark Side of the Moon' closely followed by 'Wish You Were Here'. Some of the songs on 'The Wall' like Comfortably Numb are amongst my favourite ever Pink Floyd songs, but as a whole album I don't like it as much as some of the others. Kind of like 'Piper at the Gates of Dawn' just for a laugh sometimes too....

 

R.I.P Syd !!!!!

 

umma gumma and atom heart mother
i love ''comfortably numb'' and '' wish you were here''

 

piper at the gates of dawn, has to be there best work.

 

piper's good, saucerful is better
IMHO