I have a dilemma

I slept with 2 sisters on friday night. Literally just slept with them, didn't have sex. They both like me, I like them both, don't know which one to call. I had an equally good night with both, they're almost perfectly equal in my eyes... what's my move?

 

Maybe go for the one you have more of a connection with.

Tiffany

 

At the same time? You're in a mess and my advice is to not bother with either since they both like you.

 

I'm sorry but society disapproves of incest.

 

It's messy. Someone is going to get pissed off either way.

If you really dont care who you end up with, then: Let one of them make the move. If you call one of them, then the other is going to be pissed off with you. But, if you let one of them call you, then you can honestly turn around and say to the other one: "Hey, I didnt call her. She called me. You should have called me before she did, if you felt that way."

Then it'll become an issue between them. Not you.

Yeah. Pretty underhanded, I know.

 

Do the two girls know eachother?

 

They are sisters...


I say attempt to talk to them both together (about this) and see if you can spend some time with them individualy...and see which one you truly prefer. Or flip a coin.

 

Fuck 'em both, see which one's better in the sack.

 

lol, are you joking, or did you think by sisters I meant black chicks?

 

Oh lol sorry I missed that

 

there's some sound advice


I think you're better off steering clear of the situation all together, it will inevitably get messy and someone will end up hurt/jealous.
Be friends with them both, and let them work it out....

 

No it won't I had the same situation with my sister, she got him. I was fine with it.

 

perhaps it worked out well in your situation, I've seen it crash and burn with friends, everyone is different and it depends on the closeness of the sisters....there is a lot of jealousy when it comes to sisters, not always, but it happens.

 

Well one of them just sent me a message tonight, but this makes things more complicated. I told her I had a good time, and we should catch up again soon. She said she'd like to.

Ok now, am I suppose to just call her to take her out, or should I invite both out? If I invite both, they'll both think I'm not into either (possibly), If I only invite the one who messaged me (and she was the one who fell asleep, the other sis is the one I fooled around a bit with), then the other will think I'm not into her.

 

Just go for the one you want and stop making things more complicated by messing with both of them!

 

Don't mess with either. You're already making this shit a mess.

 

Holy crap, every guy's dream and every guy's nightmare?

Umm, that is a tough one. Esp if you fooled around with the sister who didn't call, she might be waiting for you to call now that she has fooled around with you and let you know she is into you. Do you know who you prefer? Don't ask both out, you need to make your decision before taking one of tem out, in my opinion. I vote the one you fooled around with

 

I agree with Toolmaggot. But you should let them know that this is a competition so they will bring their A-Game to the party.

 

I agree with her.

 

So what's your question? Which one to do first?

Seriously, this obviously isn't a love-relationship thing --if it were, you wouldn't consider it a dilemna -- so as long as you don't tell any lies, go ahead and sleep with them both if things go that way. It might be an experience of a lifetime to tell one, "I thinking about having sex with your sister," and see what happens. You might have to duck, or you might end up in the sack with both of them.