America: Both Religious and Ignorant about Religion

dotadave · Jan 16, 2005

Article published Jan 16, 2005
U.S. a nation of faith filled with religious illiterates

By STEPHEN PROTHERO
Special to the Los Angeles Times

The sociologist Peter Berger once remarked that if India is the most religious country in the world and Sweden the least, then the United States is a nation of Indians ruled by Swedes. Not anymore.

With a Jesus lover in the Oval Office and a faith-based party in control of both houses of Congress, the United States is undeniably a nation of believers ruled by the same.

Things are different in Europe, and not just in Sweden. The Dutch are four times less likely than Americans to believe in miracles, hell and biblical inerrancy. The euro does not trust in God.

But here is the paradox: Although Americans are far more religious than Europeans, they know far less about religion.

In Europe, religious education is the rule from the elementary grades on. So Austrians, Norwegians and the Irish can tell you about the Seven Deadly Sins or the Five Pillars of Islam.

But, according to a 1997 poll, only one out of three U.S. citizens was able to name the most basic of Christian texts, the four Gospels, and 12 percent thought Noah’s wife was Joan of Arc.

That paints a picture of a nation that believes God speaks in Scripture but that can’t be bothered to read what he has to say.

U.S. Catholics, evangelicals and Jews have been lamenting for some time a crisis of religious literacy in their ranks. But the dangers of religious ignorance are by no means confined to those worried about catechizing their children or cultivating the next generation of clergy.

When Americans debated slavery, almost exclusively on the basis of the Bible, people of all races and classes could follow the debate. They could make sense of its references to the runaway slave in the New Testament book of Philemon and to the year of jubilee, when slaves could be freed, in the Old Testament book of Leviticus.

Today it is a rare American who can engage with any sophistication in biblically inflected arguments about gay marriage, abortion or stem cell research.

Since 9/11, President Bush has been telling us that “Islam is a religion of peace,” while evangelist Franklin Graham (Billy’s son) has insisted otherwise. Who is right?

Americans have no way to tell because they know virtually nothing about Islam. Such ignorance imperils our public life, putting citizens in the thrall of talking heads.

How did this happen? How did one of the most religious countries in the world become a nation of religious illiterates?

Religious congregations are surely at fault. Churches and synagogues that once inculcated the “fourth R” are now telling the faithful stories “ripped from the headlines” rather than teaching them the Ten Commandments or parsing the Sermon on the Mount (which was delivered, as only one in three Americans can tell you, by Jesus). But most of the fault lies in our elementary and secondary schools.

In a majority opinion in a 1963 church-state case (Abington vs. Schempp), Supreme Court Justice Tom Clark wrote, “It might well be said that one’s education is not complete without a study of comparative religion . . . and its relationship to the advance of civilization.”

If so, the education of nearly every public school student in the nation is woefully inadequate. Because of misunderstandings about the First Amendment, religious studies are seldom taught in public schools.

When they are, instruction typically begins only in high school and with teachers not trained in the subtle distinction between teaching religion (unconstitutional) and teaching about religion (essential).

Though state educational standards no longer ignore religion as they did a decade or so ago, coverage of religion in history and social science textbooks is spotty at best.

According to Charles Haynes, senior scholar at the First Amendment Center in Arlington, Va., “It is as if we got freedom of religion in 1791 and then we were free from religion after that.”

Now that the religious right has triumphed over the secular left, every politician seems determined to get religion. They’re all asking “What Would Jesus Do?” - about the war in Iraq, gay marriage, poverty and Social Security.

And though the ACLU may rage, it is not un-American to bring religious reasoning into our public debates. In fact, that has been happening ever since George Washington put his hand on a Bible and swore to uphold the Constitution.

What is un-American is to give those debates over to televangelists of either the secular or the religious variety, to absent ourselves from the discussion by ignorance.

A few days after 9/11, a turbaned Indian American man was shot and killed in Arizona by a bigot who believed the man’s dress marked him as a Muslim.

But what killed Balbir Singh Sodhi (who was not a Muslim but a Sikh) was not so much bigotry as ignorance.

The moral of his story is not just that we need more tolerance. It is that Americans - of both the religious and the secular variety - need to understand religion.

Resolving in 2005 to read for yourself either the Bible or the Quran (or both) might not be a bad place to start.
Click to expand...

http://www.nashuatelegraph.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20050116/OPINION04/101160014/-1/opinion

Kandahar · Jan 17, 2005

Very interesting article, and I must say that I agree with its sentiments. While I'm a strong supporter of the separation of church and state, you are absolutely right that people need to be educated in religion. In my opinion, this is for the same reasons that they need to be educated in English or history. No one should be forced to believe in any religion, but I think it's obvious that religion has played a major role in who we are as a species. To ignore it would be to ignore a major facet of our humanity.

(And I'm an atheist)

dotadave · Jan 17, 2005

Kandahar said:

Very interesting article, and I must say that I agree with its sentiments. While I'm a strong supporter of the separation of church and state, you are absolutely right that people need to be educated in religion. In my opinion, this is for the same reasons that they need to be educated in English or history. No one should be forced to believe in any religion, but I think it's obvious that religion has played a major role in who we are as a species. To ignore it would be to ignore a major facet of our humanity.

(And I'm an atheist)
Click to expand...

Or at least educated in a religion that they claim to believe in.

I'm amazed by all the people who thought Joan of Arc was Noah's wife. That was a joke in Bill and Ted's Excellent Adventure. I wonder if anybody thought Ceasar was the salad dressing dude.

BlackGuardXIII · Jan 17, 2005

A few days after 9/11, a turbaned Indian American man was shot and killed in Arizona by a bigot who believed the man’s dress marked him as a Muslim.

But what killed Balbir Singh Sodhi (who was not a Muslim but a Sikh) was not so much bigotry as ignorance.

from Article published Jan 16, 2005
U.S. a nation of faith filled with religious illiterates

By STEPHEN PROTHERO
Special to the Los Angeles Times

I disagree, it was indeed ignorance, but you can be ignorant and not be a murderous bigot. Lots of uneducated folk are not bigots. This killer was a bigot who killed Mr. Sodhi out of a deep hatred of anyone who looked like that.
The crusaders did the same in Jerusalem, they killed the Muslims and the Jews, and they killed the Christians too, just cuz they dressed funny.

HuckFinn · Jan 17, 2005

Mass consumer culture is the heart of the problem depicted in this article. Pop religion is no less shallow than pop music. Unfortunately, many churches are immersed in the commercialism and materialism that permeates American society.

superNova · Jan 17, 2005

very good article. i definitely think comparative religious studies should be taught in the public school system - separation of church and state = smart; pretending church does not exist = stupid.

Log in or Sign up

America: Both Religious and Ignorant about Religion

dotadave Member

Kandahar Banned

dotadave Member

BlackGuardXIII fera festiva

HuckFinn Senior Member

superNova Member

Share This Page

Log in or Sign up

America: Both Religious and Ignorant about Religion

dotadave Member

Kandahar Banned

dotadave Member

BlackGuardXIII fera festiva

HuckFinn Senior Member

superNova Member

Share This Page

Useful Searches