Should I read Harry Potter or Lord of the Rings?

Discussion in 'Fantasy Books' started by PinkFloydrulez, Jan 7, 2011.

  1. Piaf

    Piaf Senior Member

    Messages:
    25,272
    Likes Received:
    1,892
    And that doesn't make it any less Christian.

    Either way, it's a masterpiece.
     
  2. Asmodean

    Asmodean Slo motion rider

    Messages:
    50,556
    Likes Received:
    10,126
    Certainly not less catholic :-D
     
  3. Piaf

    Piaf Senior Member

    Messages:
    25,272
    Likes Received:
    1,892
    Yeah yeah yeah.

    Not only in the way you're thinking.
     
  4. BlackBillBlake

    BlackBillBlake resigned HipForums Supporter

    Messages:
    11,504
    Likes Received:
    1,543
    C.S.Lewis (who I don't think was as good as JRR) was a friend of Tolkien and an Anglican. I think that comes through much more in his fantasy writing than Tolkien's Catholicism. At least it's more overt.
     
  5. The Walking Dickhead

    The Walking Dickhead orbiter of helion

    Messages:
    2,878
    Likes Received:
    552
    You don't need to read anything anymore, everything has been made into a film now
     
  6. StellarCoon

    StellarCoon Dr. Professor

    Messages:
    2,703
    Likes Received:
    1,358
  7. Rots in hell

    Rots in hell Senior Member

    Messages:
    11,133
    Likes Received:
    7,213
    If you Like The LOTR Books you Will Love and be able to grock ( because it is not a lightweight ) this !
    Probably my Favorite Book
    http://youtu.be/KEiOMQM0A5I
     
  8. Rots in hell

    Rots in hell Senior Member

    Messages:
    11,133
    Likes Received:
    7,213
    part two The return
    http://youtu.be/EZ1fFqVr2Bw
     
  9. TrumpCards

    TrumpCards Visitor

    I doubt the original TC will read this, but perhaps someone will still appreciate this post.

    I’m going to be the odd man out on this one and say there are many significantly better fantasy series out there. I thought LotR was pretty bad. If I could go back and do it again, I would have just watched the movies. Harry Potter is ok, but it really starts to go downhill after the fourth book. Here’s why: in the first four, there are subtle hints that can help you predict the endings, so it has mystery elements. In the last three books, they trade that for action sequences. Now, in a video game or a movie, action and combat is better. But in a book, I think mystery elements is better. Does anyone else agree with me, or can at least understand my reasoning?
     
  10. Irminsul

    Irminsul Valkyrie

    Messages:
    62
    Likes Received:
    105
    I'm gonna go out on a limb ans suggest the skyrim main storyline is more entertaining than LOTR. Hobbits are whack as fuck anyway with hairy feet errh.
     
  11. Deidre

    Deidre Visitor

    I’ve read LoTR and not the HP series, so I’m biased. I say LoTR. But my friends who have read HP have loved it!
     
  12. makihiko

    makihiko Official hippie since 2005

    Messages:
    743
    Likes Received:
    86
    you could just read them both?

    I read HP, but never got into LOTR, I found the writing style in LOTR to be too much for me to be able to get into the flow.
     
  13. bowl_of_raspberries

    bowl_of_raspberries Member

    Messages:
    83
    Likes Received:
    19
    Read Harry Potter first. It’s far more accessible and arguably more entertaining. Once you get past the first book, they are also written extremely well.

    The Lord of the Rings is a totally different kind of story. It’s a very rewarding book to get into, but slower and not as good an introduction to fantasy. I think of it more as a retelling of an ancient saga than a modern novel. The prose and pace is closer to the style of 19th century adventure writers than Rowling’s (comparatively) modern voice (and that’s not as complimentary a statement as you might think).

    I don’t mean to downplay Tolkien’s huge accomplishment or imply that I don’t like the books - I love them - but they have to be taken on their own terms and if you want an introduction to fantasy I don’t think they’re a great place to start.
     
  14. goodearth

    goodearth Member

    Messages:
    447
    Likes Received:
    224
    I tried reading Harry Potter, but couldn’t take the fifth-grader style of writing. The story is good so just watch the movie. Both the story and the writing is good in Lord of the Rings. The best writer I have ever read is Stephen King, but his stories scare the crap out of me.
     
  15. soulcompromise

    soulcompromise Member HipForums Supporter

    Messages:
    22,105
    Likes Received:
    11,610
    My bet is on Harry for the better book. I've read Lord of the Rings. There are 3 or 4 books in the main story. It was a long time ago, but anyway they're classics. I tried reading some of Tolkien's other books too with limited success. He lost me at "The Silmarillion". Edit:

    I shouldn't provide such a scathing review. Tolkien is brilliant to be sure. But Potter might prove the lighter read.
     
    Last edited: May 11, 2018
  16. TrumpCards

    TrumpCards Visitor

    Stephen King is overrated. I really enjoyed “Misery”? but every other book of his I read was garbage.
     
  17. Tyrsonswood

    Tyrsonswood Senior Moment Lifetime Supporter

    Messages:
    34,218
    Likes Received:
    26,293

    I've read The Silmarillion more than ten times... Fantastic story and it's the back history for the other books. (The Hobbit, and Lord Of The Rings)
     
    soulcompromise likes this.
  18. Alternative_Thinker

    Alternative_Thinker Darth Mysterious

    Messages:
    5,144
    Likes Received:
    464
    I'd say Harry Potter first if you're not much of a reader, and/or if English is not your first language but would like to read in English. Harry Potter books is easier to read, fast-paced, and quite many find the story to be very entertaining. Lord of the Rings is a more challenging read, but it's got some serious stuff inside. So I'd say build your strength with HP first and then tackle LOTR.

    Mind you, I haven't even finished reading all of HP due to some personal trauma of sorts, and I quickly put down LOTR for the aforementioned reasons, but that's my case, lol.
     
  19. Asmodean

    Asmodean Slo motion rider

    Messages:
    50,556
    Likes Received:
    10,126
    I can see why so many LotR or The hobbit fans stagnate in it though. But... their loss!
     
  20. WOLF ANGEL

    WOLF ANGEL Senior Member - A Fool on the Hill Lifetime Supporter

    Messages:
    67,053
    Likes Received:
    23,650
    For me:-
    Harry Potter is more a coming of age - from a Child to a Magician, with a few back stories that come together in the end
    LOTR (Hobbit (and perhaps the Silmarillion?)) is more a Collection of stories from/of various back stories of which many could stand in their own right as story/films - which though may not culminate, never the less are integral to the ending ... of witch the stories seems never-ending
    I guess it's a matter of if one wants to follow an individual's journey, or where one (hobbit) is only one sum of many parts
     

Share This Page

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice