So I woke up this morning and my dating site in-box was completely empty. I wrote out along honest and intelligent message describing myself and the kind of women I'm looking for. I then cut and pasted it to all the women in my criteria. after about a half hour of this, I received 45 positive responses from 10 women today alone. Anymore and you could call it a harem! some of them I feel like I could easily fall in love with. If you haven't tried this I highly recommend it.
What is an 18 year old doing on a dating site? Get out there in real life! You don't need the aid of cyber space yet...Hell, I don't need it yet either!
Internet hook ups creep me out a bit. I know people who do it, these girls look sometimes no so similar to their pictures it seems. Plus hiding behind words on a screen really leaves actual conversation a little mundane the day it comes. Most people I have ever met in person after meeting them online seem really coy, and often not as interesting. Good luck if that's what you like. But at 18 you should be just out meeting people everywhere and anywhere else.
I lived in a small town too. Are you going to college? If not, once you are done with highschool, move to a more populated area and get an apartment. At 30 maybe it is time to panic, for now, I suggest you go out and enjoy life. Do things that are interesting, and interesting people will come. Also, how old are the women you are emailing? If they are under 20, they probably have no redeemable qualities in real life. Most half decent women do not need online dating at such a young age.